One of the best times to evaluate the performance of a game is right after the game is over. You may want to discuss it with the team while it is fresh in their mind or you can sit down with your coaches and go over the check list. I found it useful to go through the Basic Softball Game Evaluation Sheet with the team after the game and then again with the coaches. At the following practice would be a good time to compare your results with the players results. A great tool for developing improvement strategies.
Basic Softball Game Evaluation Sheet